In Negotiations, How Tough Should Your First Offer Be? Scientists Found Out What Works Best

In Negotiations, how tough should your first offer be? New research shows the first offer can have a significant impact on the eventual outcome, and if you try to drive too hard a bargain, it could backfire.

Whether you’re buying a house, a car, or second-hand furniture, it’s likely you will need to negotiate the price, so being able to negotiate effectively could save you significant cash.

Behavioral economist Professor Lionel Page from the University of Technology Sydney (UTS) said opening offers in real-world negotiations are sometimes intended to signal the “toughness” of the buyer–but whether this strategy actually works was not known.

“This experiment allowed us to study whether and how the level of the opening offer influences the beliefs of buyers and sellers, their actions, and the final bargaining outcome,” said Professor Page.

The researchers conducted the experiment using a bargaining game where players exchanged offers for a split of $10. The aim was to mimic the start of a typical negotiations process.

They found that the success or failure of negotiations depended not only on the final offer on the table but also on the emerging dynamics of the bargaining process.

“The intermediary offers made during negotiations can be interpreted as suggesting either kind and compromising intentions, or unkind and uncompromising ones,” said Professor Page.

RELATED: If You Want to Master a New Skill Take Plenty of Breaks While Practicing

“And the perception of these intentions can, in turn, influence the final outcome. Low offers are perceived as disrespectful, so players react negatively and can be spiteful in their counter-offers.

“In a substantial number of cases, the responder chose a “punishing” counter-offer that was lower than what he believed was the buyer’s minimum acceptable amount,” he said.

This means it is not the best strategy to always be as tough as possible in a negotiation.

Previously there have been two conflicting views on first offers in negotiations, said Professor Page.

One view is that a low opening offer works as an “anchor” that moves the final offer in the direction of the first offer.

The second is that a more reasonable initial offer achieves a better outcome because it doesn’t sour the atmosphere and endanger the agreement.

Professor Page said their study–published in Theory and Decision–showed support for both these ideas.

MORE: A Certain Kind of Smiling Can Repair Relationships that Have Been Damaged by Mistrust

“We found that there is a small window where an offer is lower than an equal split, but not so low that it triggers negative emotions. It was viewed as ‘fair game’ to start the negotiation at this point.”

So in summary to strike a good bargain your opening offer needs to be not too hard, or you risk a spiteful counter-offer, but not too soft either, or you might be taken for a ride.

In a negotiation, how tough should your first offer be? New research shows the first offer can have a significant impact on the eventual outcome, and if you try to drive too hard a bargain, it could backfire. Whether you’re buying a house, a car, or second-hand furniture, it’s likely you will need to negotiate […]
The post In Negotiations, How Tough Should Your First Offer Be? Scientists Found Out What Works Best appeared first on Good News Network. In a negotiation, how tough should your first offer be? New research shows the first offer can have a significant impact on the eventual outcome, and if you try to drive too hard a bargain, it could backfire. Whether you’re buying a house, a car, or second-hand furniture, it’s likely you will need to negotiate […]
The post In Negotiations, How Tough Should Your First Offer Be? Scientists Found Out What Works Best appeared first on Good News Network. Read MoreFeedzy

Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin
Share on pinterest
Share on email
Share on print
Share on tumblr
Positive News

Positive News

Positive News is the magazine for good journalism about good things.

When much of the media is full of doom and gloom, instead Positive News is the first media organisation in the world that is dedicated to quality, independent reporting about what’s going right.

We are pioneers of ‘constructive journalism’ – a new approach in the media, which is about rigorous and relevant journalism that is focused on progress, possibility, and solutions. We publish daily online and Positive News magazine is published quarterly in print.

As a magazine and a movement, we are changing the news for good

View Feed

Get updates on Music Festival tickets, news and special offers!

The 60s had WoodStock. 
The 80s had LiveAid. 
This generation deserves a celebration.
Live concert on every continent and streamed globally to raise awareness and funds for children around the world.
Be a Part of History

Welcome to the The Laughing Otter Community.

Great to see you!

Join a vibrant community full of happiness.

Sign Up for Free Today!

You will now be kept up to date on all things The Laughing Otter Music Festival.
Please share with all of your friends.